Wednesday, April 1, 2009

Casting Stones from a Gunboat

Check this article. If you're Filipino and on the internet, then statistically speaking, chances are your stomach is twisting, your eyes are popping bloodshot, and you're typing so hard you're about to break your macbook air in half. Did that sumvabitch really just take a dump on my country, my people???

People are pissed. Google for Chip Tsao and you'll find that not only is the article in question not on the front page, but almost all the entries are some forms of how-dare-hes peppered with the occasional say-it-to-my-face-tangina-mo. First line on the page as of this writing says Roilo Golez wants to take him on in a boxing match, a brutal one-rounder! Of course, it'll be the longest round of Chip Tsao's life before Golez goes and lays his chip ass out.

Righteous furor, right? Are you mad? Are you angry? Kumukulo na ba yung ebak mo sa galit? If so, then just let that shit simmer for a bit because congratulations, you're completely wrong.

Doesn't anyone read The Onion anymore? I'm loath to go on and explain Chip Tsao's point, because I find it hard and painful to believe that we as a society have sunk so low, so low that our jokes have to be explained to us like we do for the slow kid in class. Is our noble maharlika blood so volatile, so raging that we have no capacity to distinguish between satire and hard news? Is our chocolate-colored skin so thin that no one can poke fun at us anymore? Better call Rex Navarette and all those other malansang isda, because they're next. No one shits on the Philippines and gets away without Roilo Golez's fistprints on his grills.

More seriously, however, I am troubled by the deeper implications of all this outrage, implications which point to the nature of Filipino identity itself. One of the most incendiary portions of Tsao's column is this line:

As a nation of servants, you don't flex your muscles at your master, from whom you earn most of your bread and butter.

So after he goes on about browbeating the poor Filipina in his home, he calls us a colony of maids. Helpers. Yayas. And this is making a lot of people very very angry. "We're not all maids, you know! In case you're not aware, Filipinos have gone on to be successful everywhere!"

Because, of course, there's nothing successful about being a maid. Because it's a lowly job that is only done by those who can't do anything else. Because there's nothing great about leaving the comfort and familiarity of your homeland, going to a strange place and prostrating yourself before strange people, and being far, far away from the parents, children, brothers and sisters who by your toilings are fed and clothed. Tell me, is there not a more noble and patriotic sacrifice than this?

It's truth that most of the Filipinos in Hong Kong are there as domestic helpers in the homes of wealthy Chinese. Anyone who denies this needs to comb the gravel out of their hair and get some sunlight. But there is nothing that should offend us about this truth. The only people who are offended by this acknowledgment are those who deride the profession of the Filipino domestic helper and see it as something degrading to Filipinos. What message are we sending to domestic helpers when we bristle at that description and want nothing to do with them? What was that line about loving your countrymen?

Chip Tsao has nothing to apologize for, other than an unfamiliarity with the temper of Filipino society. The only people who should be apologizing are the bigots who continue to look upon domestic helpers as second-class human beings.

11 comments:

  1. I think you're the one missing the point. Filipinos are angry not because Chip Tsao pointed out the obvious (and yes, you're right there is nothing wrong with being a maid), Filipinos are angry because of the way he blatanly looks down on our country and people, telling us what we can and cannot do, given our plight in life. It's not an issue of Filipinos being defensive about being a nation of maids...it's an issue of having an obviously unenlightened person telling the whole world how appalled he is that Filipinos had the audacity to flex their muscles. So, sorry to have to point out the fact that Filipinos have not lost their sense of humor. They just know how to tell the difference between something that is genuinely funny and something that leaves a bad taste in the mouth. Learn the difference my friend.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I understand where u are coming from.
    There's definitely nothing wrong with being a servant for it truly is an honorable job. Whoever degrades a Filipino servant, may it be another Filipino for that matter, needs some mind and conscience cleaning. Chip Tsao may not have been really triggering on us Filipinos but his countrymen BUT, HIS USE OF ANOTHER NATION TO MOCK HIS OWN COUNTRY IS WHERE I THINK HE WENT WRONG. Nobody deprives him to write any satire he desires pertaining to his country but to do that while mocking/degrading other nation EVEN WITHOUT MEANING IT is just plain unethical. Of course he may argue that we all have our right to our own opinions and that is what Filipinos are also exercising right now.

    I am also aware that this issue have somewhat gotten out of hand already to the point that some Filipinos have made it like a Chinese vs Filipinos war instead of just against Chip Tsao. I can't blame anyone though for we, as a nation with forefathers/heroes who fought for our country, has nationalistic blood running through our veins and IT WOULD BE MORE SHAMEFUL IF WE JUST SIT AND BE APATHETIC. This should be an ANTI-RACISM/ANTI-DISCRIMINATION/ANTI-STEREOTYPING fight and hopefully this whole issue would set as an example to all other people with racist tendencies in other countries who discriminate not just against Filipinos but against other race as well.

    In addition, we Filipinos have long been criticizing our countrymen's wrong doing and expressing our thoughts on things and there's nothing wrong with that. We do not need other people to criticize us and we shouldn't discriminate against another nation just so we can make our points clear to our countrymen. That's what Chip Tsao should have realized.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I beg to differ. Chip Tsao has everything to apologize for. HIS USE OF THE PHILIPPINES TO MOCK HIS OWN COUNTRY is where I think he went terribly wrong. More importantly, what really got my blood boiling is HOW HE TREATED HIS FILIPINA MAID, treating her like an idiot. Chip Tsao just attacked our unsung heroes, the OFWS. AND FOR THE RECORD, BEING A DOMESTIC HELPER IS AN HONORABLE JOB.It is for the very same reason why many Filipinos got outraged. Isnt it enough that our domestic helpers suffer through loneliness and sacrifices but to be used as a laughingstock and treated inferiorly??
    As quoted in his article, "Their maids have been made to shout “China, Madam/Sir” loudly whenever they hear the word “Spratly.” They say the indoctrination is working as wonderfully as when we used to shout, “Long live Chairman Mao!” at the sight of a portrait of our Great Leader during the Cultural Revolution. I’m not sure if that’s going a bit too far, at least for the time being." What do you make of that? Thats abuse and discrimination for crying out loud! And you still consider this a JOKE? And dont tell me about the article being satire.! Satire or not he could have done away with the insults.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Wow, lots of people got Modest Proposal'd with that one.

    ReplyDelete
  5. #1 - It'd be true if this was in fact the case. What Chip Tsao was doing in his article though was acting as a faux-mouthpiece for the chauvinistic attitudes of the Chinese government and many Chinese who do in fact look down on Filipinos in this way. Just because he stated some opinions does not mean he subscribes to them.

    #2 - If anything, I think Chip Tsao is doing Filipinos a great service in the way of fighting negative stereotypes and racism against Filipinos. His caricatures have root in reality, and without a doubt some Hong Kongers do in fact treat their Filipino domestic help in such a way. By treating the issue with a touch of reductio ad absurdum he draws attention to the negativity that Chinese feel towards Filipinos and how outrageous the treatment of Filipinos gets sometimes.

    #3 - Perhaps it's my excessive faith in the goodness of man, but I am quite sure that despite the stories we read in the paper, that is likely not how Chip Tsao treats his maid. No one intelligent enough to write at that level would admit to something that brazen.

    He was using a caricaturized illustration of Chinese chauvinism and anti-Filipino mentality to make his point. We as a people should not be disturbed by something so minor.

    #4 - I think that's exactly what's going on here.

    ReplyDelete
  6. "#3 - Perhaps it's my excessive faith in the goodness of man, but I am quite sure that despite the stories we read in the paper, that is likely not how Chip Tsao treats his maid. No one intelligent enough to write at that level would admit to something that brazen."

    That's quite a big generalisation to make my friend. Sad to say that not every articulate 'intelligent' person possesses basic decorum. As a matter of fact, some of the most influential minds in the world have been known for their erratic behaviour and lack of manners. Beethoven, for example, was a musical genius, however not a genius when it came to manners. So whether Chip Tsao really did treat his maid that way... who knows? But if he did, naturally it's wrong, if not, it definitely spices up his article.

    In spite of that see your point in that Chip Tsao was just pointing out the flaws of his own country. Although it may seem like a harsh blow against Filipinos I do agree the intention of his article was more or less the converse and if you actually read some of George Orwell's satirical essays on how the Irish are treated by the English you can actually draw parallels.

    With that I aside, I nevertheless think you may be blaming the wrong people for this misunderstanding. I came across this whole debate through the Filipino News and being told by my Mum. I'll admit, like many, I haven't read the article, so I naïvely believed the context the news put the article in... which was that Chip Tsao was nothing more than an anti-Filipino xenophobe. I'd like to thank you for shedding light on this topic, and it's a shame that the news doesn't deliver the whole story but rather takes its own spin on the issue and backs this up with a few measly quotes. This kind of reminds me of Filipinos' huge overreaction to a line about Filipino universities in Desperate Housewives... Ridiculous.

    Thanks for this blog post and I hope next time news sources will take a deep breath and relax next time something like this comes along.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Gosh, we're a dramatic race, aren't we?

    ReplyDelete
  8. say all you want. say all the deepest English words you can get just to defend your blog. i cant understand some of them, really :D. still, mr. tsao hurts the feelings of our fellow countrymen. that's it.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Absolutely right. And the English will be as deep as I see fit.

    ReplyDelete
  10. To other commenters, browse around the internet and look for all the racist drivel you can find on the blacks, the Chinese, the Mexicans and whoever else. I can assure you that you'll find at least twenty times the hits on Google alone when you compare it to racism against Filipinos.

    The thing is, the other races don't care what people say about them. That's because they know they contribute something to society. Filipinos have a perennial chip on their shoulder. We're insecure about our societal worth and that's why we're angry.

    And that's why I'm angry, not necessarily because of dramatic Filipinos, but because of their insecurity. We're awesome, we don't have to give a **** about what's written on a no-name rag. Making such a big fuss about it only shows that 1. we're insecure and 2. nobody writes enough media about us.

    Moreover, I'd like to point out that Filipinos are very guilty of racism as well. The very fact that Joey de Leon can call a black man in Takeshi's Castle "Kobe" and get away with it attests to this fact. Michael V got away with making a racist song about "Bombays" as well. We're not really in a position to get angry, are we?

    ReplyDelete
  11. Never heard of Chip Tsao before now. He is wickedly funny! Without this controversy I would still know nothing about him.
    Now I want to see who else he's provoked - they probably had the sense to ignore him.

    ReplyDelete